Idaho parents, child care providers ask Legislature to reverse budget cuts as closures begin

Idaho House speaker says $79M axed from child care budget ‘hasn’t been on my radar’

By: - March 8, 2023 2:54 pm
A crowd of mostly women on the steps of the Idaho State Capitol building, holding signs that are supportive of child care workers

Child care providers, teachers and parents gathered at the Idaho State Capitol building on Wednesday, March 8, to urge the Idaho Legislature to reinstate $79 million of child care assistance that was removed from budgets last month. (Audrey Dutton/Idaho Capital Sun)

Lakewood Montessori in Boise took a string of financial hits from the COVID-19 pandemic — from closures in early 2020 to ongoing inflation and worker shortages.

And, like other Idaho child care centers, Lakewood used federal grants from the American Rescue Plan Act to add $300 a month to the paychecks of its employees.

Lakewood co-owner Mary Clements expected the ARPA grants to run out by September or even June. So, the school, which educates toddlers through kindergarten students, told parents that a 7% to 10% tuition increase was on the way for the coming school year.

That was before the Idaho Legislature’s Joint Finance-Appropriations Committee voted Feb. 27 not to distribute any remaining ARPA child care funds — neither $36 million in federally funded grants that Health and Welfare would distribute from July through September, nor $43 million in remaining federal allocations for Idaho to spend on child care grants until July.

Idaho budget committee votes to cut funding for child care, family supports

“Had we known what JFAC was going to do, our business plan would have changed significantly,” Clements said. “I’m very nervous about steps we will have to take to make our budget work if the wage enhancements and grants are not reinstated. Ultimately, extra costs will land on the shoulders of parents.”

The budget approved by JFAC must also be approved in the House and Senate. It hasn’t yet come up for a vote in either chamber.

The morning of March 1, Clements and other child care providers received an email from the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare.

“Because the budget request was not approved, March 2023 will be the final child care grant payment, and this final payment amount may be modified due to limitations in our budget,” said the email, signed by the department’s child care program manager. “If the legislature later approves the ongoing use of the funds for the grants, I will write again with another update for all participants.”

If the budget goes through the Idaho Legislature without an authorization to spend the federal funds, Lakewood will have to “raise tuition significantly right away,” Clements said. “… And it most likely won’t be enough.”

Child care providers, supporters gather at Idaho Statehouse in Boise

Child care providers, parents and children gathered at the Capitol in Boise to demonstrate Wednesday to call attention to what they say is an impending crisis. After the rally, they went inside the Capitol to appeal to lawmakers to reinstate the funding in time to route the federal grants to child care providers in Idaho, instead of returning the money to the federal government to be reallocated to other states.

A person stands on the steps of Idaho Capitol building with a child who is toddler aged
Parents brought their children to the Capitol in Boise on Wednesday, March 8, to demonstrate with child care workers in support of grant funding. (Audrey Dutton/Idaho Capital Sun)

Two hours after the rally on the steps of the Capitol, Idaho legislative leaders spoke at a press conference hosted by the Idaho Press Club.

House Speaker Mike Moyle, R-Star, said he was unaware of JFAC’s decision to approve a budget without the child care funding. It “hasn’t been on my radar,” he said, later suggesting that legislators may approve the funds separately in these final weeks of the session.

Senate President Pro Tem Chuck Winder, R-Boise, said he was unaware of the reason behind JFAC’s vote but said he intends to investigate it further.

House and Senate Democratic leaders Sen. Melissa Wintrow and Rep. Ilana Rubel, both from Boise, said they did not understand why JFAC would deny child care assistance.

“This is an inflection point for every other industry. Every industry in the state counts on child care access, whether you are in manufacturing or whether you’re in food services or whatever you’re in, your workers need child care,” Rubel said. “And these funds are very badly needed. I think it can still be fixed, but it’s going to be an uphill battle.”

Some Idaho centers may close, become unaffordable due to loss of child care grants

Storybook Early Learning Centers in North Idaho is among the first child care providers to decide to shutter a facility due to losing the grants now instead of in summer or fall.

Child care is a different kind of business. And it is an essential business. If everyone at a hospital who needed child care didn't have it, the hospital couldn't function, and society would suffer.

– Mary Clements, Lakewood Montessori, Boise

The business has three child care centers — in Old Town, Ponderay and Sandpoint. The ARPA child care wage enhancement grants helped maintain competitive wages at one center, while another set of child care grants through ARPA helped offset the cost of rent for the Ponderay center.

The Ponderay center was one of few child care centers with immediate openings for new children, and it was on track to be self-sustaining by summer, said Storybook CEO and President Pana Vanderholm.

JFAC’s decision to cancel the grants immediately changed the bottom line for Storybook. It must now break its lease for that property and transfer the children — whose parents wanted local child care in Ponderay — to the Sandpoint center.

That puts a strain on the Sandpoint child care center, which is already full, she said.

The ARPA child care grants were “allowing us to keep our doors open, so we could take (children who had been on) a waitlist and support families who were in the Ponderay area,” Vanderholm said.


Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Audrey Dutton
Audrey Dutton

Audrey Dutton was a senior investigative reporter with the Idaho Capital Sun after 10 years at the Idaho Statesman. Her favorite topics to cover included health care, business, consumer protection issues and white collar crime. Before coming home to Idaho, Dutton worked as a journalist in Minnesota, New York, Maryland and Washington, D.C. Dutton's work has earned dozens of state, regional and national awards for investigative reporting, health care and business reporting, data visualization and more.